Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't think the problem is OS design. Across his armful of assorted arguments, the poster made an argument that tiling managers suck, as well as some other things. That aside, I don't think it's the OS that is the problem, but rather that the computer is a gateway to many possibilities.

Your OS, and the apps on your computer, can be designed with focus and cognitive ease in mind, but it does not change the fact that a few actions away is a Stargate to another world. So, aside from a few grab-bag complaints (though legitimate) about operating systems, programmers and designers have little more to do. Apps are only going to get better designed, and minimalism and cleanliness have come to characterize modern app design.



Reading your comment I couldn't help but notice the juxtaposition of

>I don't think the problem is OS design.

>a few actions away is a Stargate to another world.

Maybe we should design the OS so that "the stargate" is a whole lot of actions away.


I don't think the user would take kindly to obstructions to their browsing / app experience...

"Why does it take an extra unnecessary step to launch an app!? You're telling me this is for my own psychological good?!"

I suppose this goes to classical arguments about the role of government in banning drugs or mandating seat belts. The state doesn't think you are responsible enough, so they create an external structure (fines / criminal penalty) to make you do good for yourself.

Others would say that a sad restriction has been placed upon them because the rest of the population cannot regulate themselves to the satisfaction of the state. It can also be argued that now people rely on external pressure or structure to behave well rather than setting up their own internal structure.


Who said anything about mandating?

I know I periodically drop

    0.0.0.0 news.ycombinator.com
    0.0.0.0 reddit.com
in my /etc/hosts file.

I also added a "don't let me switch from this window until I ask to be able to switch from this window" setting in my WM.

It doesn't have to be imposed externally to be helpful.


The problem is, I often need to access that "stargate" in the course of doing actual work (looking up documentation, Googling error messages, etc.).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: