Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


The majority of the downvotes you received almost certainly came from atheists, given the demographics of HN. You got downvoted because you wrote an uncivil and unproductive comment of a form the guidelines for "Show HN" explicitly ask you not to write; in other words, you got downvoted for writing like a jerk. Don't do that.


For the record, I did not downvote. Curious if you had a bad experience in a church, or in general why the negative sentiment.


No, it's ok.

I expected to be downvoted but I feel what I posted and believe it to be worth noting among the positive clamor.

Yes, I did have bad experiences at church as a kid, I was forced to go, it was not a good place, but more importantly I don't approve of religion in general.

I would likewise make a negative remark if a site promoting multi-level marketing, extremist politics, anti-vaccination, or something of this nature was on the front page of hacker news. I simply don't think these things are good.

Not to be dismissive of your effort... your application is awesome. I don't claim to know everything nor what everyone should do, but this doesn't change my opinion about churches. Sorry for the negative attitude. But I do have it and it is worth pointing out at minimum *some churches do harm in the world.


I'm sorry to hear that. Certainly there are bad churches in the world. But there are many many more churches that are helping meet needs (physical, mental, spiritual) in their communities. I hate that you've only seen negative affects of religion when there is so much good in spirituality and community you didn't see. :-(


Religious "good" is really selfish, mitigating the existential fear and providing "guidance" while society absorbs the negative externalities of decreased critical reasoning, departure from reality and increased sectarian tensions and so forth.

So while communally your project is beneficial, locally and globally it decreases the pace of human development as a whole.


Just doing my part! ;-)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: