Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Homeopathic Products Recalled for Containing Actual Drugs (theness.com)
22 points by tokenadult on March 24, 2014 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


Please share this with your friends. It's a great chance to show people what a dangerous scam homeopathy really is.


No, it won't do that. First people will just say this was an accident or a mistake and learn nothing at all. You will just look like chicken little.

Second homeopathy isn't dangerous - call it that and you will be the boy who cried wolf (I'm in a fable mood today I see).

And third it's not really a scam, it's a placebo. Placebos work very well, and there is an unfulfilled place for them in medicine. (Sorry, can't think of a fable for the third point.)


Second homeopathy isn't dangerous

People who believe in it choose it over medicine that might actually work. If you've got a cold (and you're not in precarious health), no harm done.

Otherwise, here's a list (including deaths) that actual medicine could have done something about ; http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html


I take your point about the value of placebos, but homeopathic practitioners don't have a monopoly on the placebo effect. And homeopathy diverts people from effective medical treatment. This kills people.

And these safety incidents aren't accidents -- they're an inevitable consequence of people taking unregulated substances as if they were medicines. When people swallow these preparation, or drop them in their eyes, or shove them up their nose or their ass, I don't think it occurs to them that nobody has checked whether this is a safe thing to do. I think they should be made aware of this.


> Homeopathy is bunk. It is 100% pure unadulterated pseudoscience.

No. It is a placebo. And a very effective one. People don't realize how effective placebos actually are.


...or a completely ineffective one, advertising itself as effective. Its fraud at the very least.


The homeopathy 'medicines' had unintentional effects in this case I presume.


I thought this was going to be an article in the Onion!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: