Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not sure we're reading the same thing. Certainly yes in Europe. I'm not a visitor, I live in the European union, and work, travel and use mobile phones extensively there.

That you bought a carrier-locked phone in France is not really relevant, as I didn't say there are not carrier-locked phones in Europe, just that the carrier system is not as it is in the US, and having unlocked phones, pre-paid cards, and even mandatory unlocking is (and has been) the norm since mid-nineties.

In France, for example, the law (in effect since 1998) states clearly that even if they sell it locked, the carrier must unlock your phone after 6 months. That's the reason the iPhone had to be sold unlocked in France even back in 2007, when there was no such option in the US.

Heck, the US didn't even have SIM cards and GSM phones until quite recently (late '00s).



"...having unlocked phones, pre-paid cards, and even mandatory unlocking is (and has been) the norm since mid-nineties." This is what I am disputing from experience. It is categorically not the norm. Phones are sold locked to contracts. Pay-as-you-go is possibly marginally more popular, but the phones are subsidised and locked. Yes they can be unlocked and normally for a fee. The French law you allude to is out of date and falls foul of Directive 2005/29/EC (see the entry on Belgium in the wiki link). There is no law in France or most other EC territories as illustrated in your link.

Phones sold, in France on pay-as-you-go (forfait bloqué) and monthly deals (forfait) come with a locked phone. Yes, they may be unlocked at any time (http://assistance.orange.fr/desimlocker-votre-mobile-2839.ph... and http://assistance.sfr.fr/mobile_forfait/mobile/desimlocker-m...), much like the can in the UK (http://service.o2.co.uk/IQ/SRVS/CGI-BIN/WEBCGI.EXE?New,Kb=Co...) or indeed in Germany (http://www.t-mobile.de/sim-lock-entsperren/0,20638,23789-_,0...). The end user must still pay the remainder of their contract even if they choose to use another provider. SIM only deals; either 30 day, PAYG or 12 month contracts, are commonplace. Suggesting that in anyway they are the norm is incorrect.

EDIT: Funnily enough one of my parents, a resident of France, has had an iPhone 3G, 3Gs, 4s and 5s on contract with Orange. Not one was sold unlocked with their contract.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: