Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> (yeah, I know about Mono)

Mono solves everything you complain about and that's the only mention it gets?



I don't know about desktop or mobile, but my experience with Mono for web applications has been pretty awful in comparison to Microsoft's implementation. I have a tremendous amount of respect for the Mono team, but it's just not a good enough replacement.

It's actually caused me to stop writing C#, because I can't stand managing Windows systems, but there isn't really a good alternative.


It's like saying "Java only works on old Nokia phones (yeah I know about all other ports of JVM)".


Not really. We've tried running several C# programs on mono, and as of a few months ago, the effort to port them so they will work on mono was pretty intense, and the performance was lacking.

C# (especially when developed in VS) is a nice language and environment, but cross-platform is not one of it's strengths.


I am sure I would have similar issues with Java on *nix because of my lack of experience with both. Cross-platform is definitely a major C# strength at least in the mobile space given the power of Xamarin tool chain. Android and iOS do matter and they are not Windows.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: