Like e.g. palaeontology, economists can't do experiments. You must remember that about economy.

I've read a bit too much criticism of economy as a science using the same argument you see from creationists against palaeontology. (That is, assumptions that all researchers are idiots and/or in a conspiracy against the creationists/left wing extremists.)

well pure paleontology is abduction is a sense. but the thing about paleontology is that it is based on biology in which we can do experiments.

Economy is arguably based on cognitive psychology and game theory. (A bit less strictly, but it should even out with all the lacking environmental parameters in paleontology...)