Remember that this isn't an incubator, so a lot of them aren't making startups. For example, Dale Stephens is doing http://www.uncollege.org/ (Organization aimed at promoting lifelong learning through "bootcamps") and Laura Deming is doing http://longevity.vc/ (VC firm aimed at funding companies trying to solve aging)
I know of a couple of exits, but I'm not actually sure which are public so I'm trying to find articles.
> Again, the Fellowship is not an accelerator, so judging it based off successful exits is a terrible criteria.
I understand that it isn't solely for startups, but the Wikipedia article mentions that as one of the types of work Thiel Fellows pursue (along with "scientific research" and "working on a social movement"). And since we're on Hacker News, which caters to the entrepreneurial crowd, it made sense to ask whether there were any successful startups or exits from the program. If we were on a site for scientific research or social movements, I would have asked for more details on any successes in those areas.
I know of a couple of exits, but I'm not actually sure which are public so I'm trying to find articles.
Some of my favorite current projects are Charlie Stigler (http://www.zaption.com/), Dylan Field (http://figma.com/) <-- Look at TC coverage to see what they are making, and Clay Allsopp (http://usepropeller.com/)
Again, the Fellowship is not an accelerator, so judging it based off successful exits is a terrible criteria.