Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is not a website. This is a massive web of communications, past and present. This is not a wire tap without a permit, this is a permanent archive of every sniffle. Guys with warrants and/or guns get what they want, and Facebook has what they want.

Does Mark Zuckerburg strike you as the kind of fella who will go to prison to fight for your privacy?



This is not a wire tap without a permit, this is a permanent archive of every sniffle

Uploaded willfully by the people concerned. What is hard to understand about "don't put something online you don't want others to have access to"? (Values of "others" change with the service involved.. but you'd have to be frankly, moronic to put something on a social network site and not expect it to be accessible to others, as well as authorities if they come knocking)


Well, that's a very simplistic view, but I'm not up for the challenge presently. If all Facebook users were legal adults, you'd be on less shaky ground.

However, I was thinking more about private messages and chats, tracking cookies, etc. Also pernicious: being tagged in other people's content.

Tying a real name to private data can have repercussions, even for responsible law abiding adults -- especially when the data is archived indefinitely, in one convenient central location.


What's so hard about it is that few individual things feel like "something you don't want others to have access to", yet in aggregate the individual things and the connections between them can become such.

On top of that you are putting the responsibility on people to "think of every bad use of this information which could happen, and if you are still happy, then post it". Which is an impossible task. Much better to enumerate what can happen, what it will be used for, which can be made a limited set of things, and then if you are happy with that, post it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: