I think a mix is the right approach. I’ve used LLMs to learn a variety of topics. I like having a good book to provide structure and a foundation to anchor my learning. Then use LLMs to explore the topics I need more help with.
When it’s just a book. I find myself having questions like you mentioned. When it’s just LLMs I feel like I don’t have any structure for my mind to hold on to.
I also feel like there is an art to picking the right order to approach learning a topic, which authors are better at than LLMs.
A good book by an expert is still better than LLMs at providing high-level priorities, a roadmap for new territory, and an introduction to the way practitioners think about their subject (though for many subjects LLMs are pretty good at this too). But the LLMs boost a book's effectiveness by being your individualized tutor.
When it’s just a book. I find myself having questions like you mentioned. When it’s just LLMs I feel like I don’t have any structure for my mind to hold on to.
I also feel like there is an art to picking the right order to approach learning a topic, which authors are better at than LLMs.