Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I had to pay hundreds of dollars in court fees after all shoplifting charges against me were dropped by the prosecutor when they noticed the person on camera was not, in fact, me, or anyone looking even remotely like me. The mall cop just grabbed the wrong person.


What jurisdiction are you in? Did you contact your elected representatives (if you have any)? Did you appeal the fees?


This was in Northampton Massachusetts about 25 years ago. I did go to UMass’s legal help clinic who told me basically “Yes, that’s how it works, it’s awful, but unless you want to spend the next few years of your life and every penny you have fighting this, just accept it and move on.”


Sometimes just paying it and moving on is in fact the simplest solution. Fighting it in the courts would have taken time and effort, and unless you could find a good pro bono lawyer, money. Fighting it in the court of public opinion is another option. Visiting you elected representatives offices for a chat about it takes a limited amount of time, but can have a big impact. Please don't misunderstand me, I am blaming you for anything or judging your decisions, I am merely offering suggestions to you and anyone else about ways to make things better :)


Can you sue the state for those charges back?


Sure, but that would have cost me way more than a couple hundred dollars. (This was about 25 years ago.)


Would a small claims court not take it, due to small amount of money involved? I appreciate it was a long time ago so it's hard to answer.


You mean … the same court and judge that imposed the fee in the first place?


No? Small claims court is a different branch of the court system.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: