Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There are more robberies than a mugging. Pick pockets are a real scourge. If you have a reliable way to turn stolen goods into currency, you are incentivized to take that item. Jewelry -> pawn shops for example.

The anti-theft measure here makes it not profitable, or much harder to profit, from taking a phone because you can't resell it or strip the valuable parts. I had a friend get pick pocketed in spain, and the next day the phone was several countries away.

Just because people can get mugged regardless of perceived wealth doesn't mean that we don't try to reduce the risk.



Do you think pickpocketer take your phone out of your pocket, check it then say "oh shit this is iphone 15 with DRM" and put it back to your pocket ?

Pickpocketers will fish anything that is in your pocket and in crowded public transport immediately pass to other partner in crime.

Same with thefts on scooter that rob woman with bags - they don't check if it's prada bag or if has any valuables inside.

Same with thefts that can even break your car window to get some bag that they see is inside but in the end has only groceries.


It's about EV per phone. The more security, the lower the EV. Eventually, it isn't even worth it for informed, career pickpockets to take it. There'll always be pickpockets, but phones are much less of a target because of measures like these.


Any impact isn't going to happen on the individual pickpocket level. It would be by making the industry unprofitable.


Moving stolen electronics for phone components has been a consistent revenue stream for a long time and there's a lot of organization that goes into it. No one is pretending this solves the problem, rather that it creates a negative incentive for targeting phones specifically.

The world of scamming and petty theft is vast. I've known some real slick thieves, and they are of the opinion that lifting a phone is just not worth it these days. However, this deterrent is obviously going to be effective on a spectrum. If someone is trying to sell you stolen goods, are you going to buy a new iphone from them on the off chance you can get parts out of it?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: