Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
A Checklist for Choosing Type (fonts.google.com)
74 points by Paul-Craft on July 19, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 20 comments


> Comic Sans is perfect for setting children’s activity timetables that are displayed in a school playground. It’s perhaps not as appropriate for announcing scientific breakthroughs.

Simon Peyton Jones would beg to differ. :)


I enjoyed his talk on adding lambdas to Excel, in general, but one particular bright spot was when someone asked why the slides weren't Comic Sans and he explained (my paraphrase...) that he had to give the talk outside Haskell circles and the rest of the world doesn't love him enough to forgive Comic Sans.


> Comic Sans is perfect for setting children’s activity timetables that are displayed in a school playground. It’s perhaps not as appropriate for announcing scientific breakthroughs.

If it was good enough to present the discovery of the Higgs boson [1], it is good enough for me.

[1] https://youtu.be/m-dNqCbRc_Y?t=26


Higgs Boson scientists are not necessarily graphics design experts. From what I’ve seen, a lot of times scientists just pick a font from Word and don’t care much about it.


But imagine the response the Higgs boson COULD have gotten by setting it in Arial instead!!!


I love how only 1 is about design and 2, 3, 4 are all technical.

> Its personality will prompt the appropriate emotional response(s) from our audience

For this to be just a bullet point, you need to understand the personality of fonts, then understand emotional responses of form, then understand audiences.

> Its design fits the intended use

Not so easy when you actually consider what this is asking. The design is what, and it applies to intent how?

The takeaway being, fonts are really really hard. They're not even supposed to stand out (your content is).


"Only" 1 is so important, in the author's opinion, it has a whole other webpage dedicated to it: https://fonts.google.com/knowledge/choosing_type/emotive_con...


Is it just me, or are there a lot of posts about typefaces on HN front page lately?


I don't know if it's what's happening here, but it's a common phenomenon in HN that a post starts a trend of posts with a similar theme. People discuss a subject, they post some links to related projects in comments, other people wander into those links and find them or the links that those pages have worthy of their own HN posts.


Overall people in software cannot stop talking about fonts


We're in kind of a golden age of font quality and variety, and have widely available screens able to actually show & benefit from the details. It's almost the only fun thing about the current stage of computers/the internet.

I think we're also individually creatively starved from a generation+ of dismissing artistic and aesthetic pursuits. It's a socially-acceptable-within-computer-people-society way to acknowledge and participate in the creation of beauty.


and yet Arial and Courier New remain the go-to fonts for me.


I'm goin to guess that the recent Commit Mono post started it, it fizzled out a tad, and the Sweden font post yesterday kicked off some additional interest


At one time today, there were at least four typeface-related threads on the front page. That seems far outside the average.


Interesting, but I was hoping for something more prescriptive. And all the articles seem to be out of order. There is no "first" article for learning about typefaces.


now if only google fonts and noto were uncensored instead of using outdated religious sensibilities to remove their practical utility...


What do you mean?


What in the world are you taking about???


what's the difference between a type and a font?


Type is very broad. Think of it as “text style”.

Typeface is a pattern for glyphs, like Helvetica.

Font is more specific. 12 point Helvetica Bold.

Font family is a group of fonts. It could have 30 specific Helvetica fonts. Different from typeface in that you’re picking specific ones. It’s an implementation versus an idea.

These words all have slightly different meanings in different contexts and they’re totally muddled in common usage.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: