Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Oh well? When the alternative being supported is, "Return to an expensive and inhumane model of frequent and revolving incarceration" I can't say that bothers me much. I'm also fairly sure that seeing a homeless junkie skin up isn't exactly an advertisement for the lifestyle.


There are options between "an inhumane system of frequent and revolving incarceration" and "never punishing public drug use under any circumstances."


And what is that option that doesn’t involve the Justice system targeting minorities and the police not killing people for trying to sell a single cigarette.


Well in France we provide methadone and subutex for free to anyone who needs it, but we also chase drug dealers, jail large consumers, do heavy prevention in schools etc.

Our goal was never to stop drug use, we know it's impossible, but to both make it survivable by victims, stop the violence on the citizens who did nothing wrong but walk past a drug victim, and also stop the spread of the victimization (that's why we hesitate so strongly about Marijuana: there's a 100% chance in increases its victims rather than reduce them).

Minorities are not the only drug victims, a lot of the victims are also in people of the mainstream cultural segment of the population. I'd even argue these victims make it all the more important to help control the problem since they have richer parents who hold more power and vote etc.

Don't lose sight of the point, the evil is the drug, not the police, in the drug fight. The victims of the drug trades are killed by the drug in 99% of the deaths, and by police abuse for the rest. It is not a police problem first and foremost.


> Minorities are not the only drug victims, a lot of the victims are also in people of the mainstream cultural segment of the population

Minorities are often the victims of the Justice system in the US. When drugs were in an “inner city” problem. It was all about “poor morals” and “absentee fathers”.

When it happened in “rural America” it was the fault of those evil “illegal immigrants” and the drug companies and “let’s treat it like a disease”.

“ It is not a police problem first and foremost.”

It is when you’re targeted because of the color of your skin.


Maybe a system of law enforcement that doesn't kill people for trying to sell a single cigarette? That seems achievable.


It actually isn’t. Since the Justice system is mostly targeting minorities, the majority doesn’t care.

It should be telling that during protests, white people were helping protestors by forming a “shield” because they knew the optics of police beating white people would be distasteful.

https://www.blackenterprise.com/white-protesters-form-human-...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: