Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Carburetors and point ignition systems have their issues.

One of which is that if you apply 12V to the coil, you can bump-start the car and it will run. Theft of such cars is truly trivial.

Modern cars are in fact very hard to steal. Just because the car from the article has a flaw that allows you to unlock and start it via canbus, doesn't mean that all modern cars can be stolen like this.



You can bring ECU from the same car, connect some wires and start any modern car just as well. Original ECU won't even know what's going on. We call it "spider". It's not as easy as just powering on ignition sparks, but similar attack.


How do you “silence” the original ECU? Won’t there be bus contention?


Sure, you will also need to drop transmission to replace that ecu too. It all depends on a car.


Modern car theft in the US is unfortunately all too easy; you point a handgun at someone in their car and tell them to give you their keys. Until those who do that are violently stopped by the state cars will be easy to steal regardless of any technical countermeasures.

Car theft is largely a political problem, not a technical one.


> One of which is that if you apply 12V to the coil, you can bump-start the car and it will run. Theft of such cars is truly trivial.

Bump start?

Just jump the starter solenoid terminals with one of those remote start buttons or a screwdriver.


Stealing car is not an only issue in keyless access. A friend of mine has lost a little bit because somebody used to open the car and steal everything costly what was in salon while the car was parked near a mall.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: