Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

And this in a nutshell is why Mastodon will always be niche and will never be a twitter replacement. Indexing every post is good and would be a solution to one of the biggest problems with Mastodon: discovering people to follow.

As it currently stands Mastodon is a very toxic community of people in the sense that they don't care at all about what the average person actually wants or needs in a network like this. Any and all complaints or comments pointing out the problems with usability are met with exactly the sort of hostility you describe here.

Hell, even as a very technical person I can't find anyone to follow on Mastodon other than developers. There was some large index of the most popular mastodon servers so I tried that and the top entry in the health category was an antivaxer spreading misinformation.

Honestly what we need is a twitter replacement, centralized, with search and recommendations. Perhaps run by a non-profit council or something.



Did it occur to you that maybe Mastodon wasn't created to cater for the average person?


I think this is the hostility he was mentioning, ROTFL


I think Mastodon or a subset of it can evolve into what you want. We'll start seeing specialized servers that vet their members. As Elon drives people away, you'll see more technical people, more serious medical people and the like.


Is your username a reference to the Minecraft server? /offtopic

This is already happening somewhat. There's at least one server I can think of off the top of my head which is invite only, and purpose focused. Hoping to get an account there eventually, though I won't say the name and drive unneeded attention to it.


It's my geocaching name, and it's because my wife's geocaching name was often abbreviated to "2b".


Hi. You are precisely the kind of threat that the Fediverse culture is designed to defend from. You should maybe consider why that is.

The Fediverse was never built nor intended to be a "Twitter replacement".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: