Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We don't know what the circumstances were around the actions this individual did or did not do. The justice system can be as corrupt as any other government institution, where wrongful verdicts and convictions are made all the time. It takes years of costly uphill legal battles to dig yourself out of that hole, and many don't make it.

That said, even if this person did commit the crime, I'm siding with GP here: what is the purpose of keeping a human being behind bars for life, if there's no chance they would eventually reintegrate into society? Solitary confinement in particular seems like a medieval torture device designed to drive people mad, rather than rehabilitate them.

If the State wants to remove someone from society altogether, the death penalty is a more humane way of doing that. A life sentence makes no sense in this system, unless someone is benefiting from keeping prisoners alive. In many ways, this is just a modern form of slavery.

Judging by this person's writing, they've somehow managed to rehabilitate themselves despite of their cruel living conditions, which is nothing short of remarkable.



> We don't know what the circumstances were around the actions this individual did or did not do.

The crimes in question were rape and murder. Are you saying you doubt he actually did those things, or that you think there are some circumstances under which they'd be justified? If the latter, can you elaborate?


I'm not defending the crimes this person may have committed. I think my points were clear, but to summarize:

- Wrongful verdicts and convictions do happen.

- Is a life sentence the appropriate retribution to society?

- The US prison system works on punishment and exploitation, rather than rehabilitation.

- This person's writing shows remarkable thinking, despite of their environment.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: