Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We have decades more experience with electrical cars. And for over 100 years, electrical cars were a curiosity. For at least half of the time we've had nuclear power we've also had people saying that electrical won't have a chance at displacing ICU cars. "Experts" being far more adamant than laypeople because they "know" it isn't going to happen.

And yet, this appears to be happening.

The thing is, arguing that "X can't happen because X hasn't happened before" isn't a proper argument because everything around you has spent more time not happening than happening.

A compelling argument is one that argues how X can't happen for reasons we can know. For instance if we bang up against hard limits imposed by natural law that we just can't get around.



There is no record of electrical car promoters systematically lying about their costs.

Electric cars were not, in fact, a practical prospect until lithium battery technology improved radically. It was not the prospect of electric cars that drove the improvement. It was cell phones. As soon as the batteries got good enough, practical electric cars started to be offered, cash on the barrelhead, what you see is what you get.

Nuke experience resembles this in exactly zero details. It is frankly weird you thought otherwise.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: