Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

there are a few things to unpack here

1) Autosteer and active safety features are not "autopilot", its adaptive cruise control.

2) if they think something bad is about to happen, it beeps and hands over control, thus its the drivers fault, as the system wasn't engaged at the time of the crash

3) its not their self driving tech.



exactly. Steer assisting and active safety features are standard features for every upper class car you buy today.


1) Autosteer + active safety features is exactly what autopilot is. What do you think it is?

2) Tesla count 5 seconds after a disengagement and count it as a fault of autopilot if a crash occurs.

3) It's part of their self driving tech, but it's different to FSD - yes.


“FSD” and “Autopilot” are both SAE level 2 systems, which by definition, never take over driving responsibility from the driver.

They may have the worlds best driver assist features, but they have yet to produce a product that drives itself in any capacity.

https://www.motorweek.org/images/SAE_Chart.png


SAE is good for classification but not for evaluating performance. By definition autosteer isn't "driving", but it does effectively drive for you at the level you'd expect, and it can take you 300 miles on a highway without disengagements and the $12k package can even overtake cars slower than you.


You’re only looking at one metric of “performance”: the number of conditions it operates in.

The SAE is looking at a different performance hurdle between levels 2 and 3: reliability.


That's my point. Mercedes might be able to operate unsupervised on a some predefined map of highways while under a set of conditions and at a certain speed, but that doesn't mean it's a good product that solves real problems if it can't take over driving unsupervised on a regular road trip where you're driving 70+mph.


> Autosteer + active safety features is exactly what autopilot is.

If you ask a normal person on the street what "autopilot" means in a car, you'll get a range of answers. But the consistent opinion is that autopilot means that you don't need to concentrate. Most will say that its automatic driving, and will drive for you.

But autosteer requires concentration. Its just sparkling lane assist.

> it's different to FSD - yes.

Which is the point. Its marketing fluff. Autopilot isn't really that, its adaptive cruise control with lane assist. Thats the thing that rankles. All of this stupidity, injury, and noise comes from a marketing decision. One designed to cover up that the CEO over promised and wildly under delivered _yet again_.


Autopilot in a plane is cruise control and flight heading (lane assist). Is that not the same thing?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: