Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because supporting depressed people is depressing and often futile. Mental illnesses can be transmissible that way.

Also, supporting a depressed person needs lots of time and effort, and while they are depressed they give nothing back except bad vibes.



> Mental illnesses can be transmissible that way.

The medical term for what you are talking about is compassion fatigue. It's symptoms look a lot like depression: "People who experience compassion fatigue may exhibit a variety of symptoms including lowered concentration, numbness or feelings of helplessness, irritability, lack of self-satisfaction, withdrawal, aches and pains, or work absenteeism."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compassion_fatigue


I'm very glad we're not friends.

edit: I just found this meme: https://i.imgur.com/WCzNW77.png and I decided to link it here. People think friendship is something that is built over years because it takes years in order to have finally made it through enough hardship and shared struggle so calling each other friends is justified. This is the literal meaning of having a friend. You know they'll help you even you got nothing to give and without expecting anything in return from them.


> You know they'll help you even you got nothing to give and without expecting anything in return from them.

I cannot decide if that is more abusive or more romanticized.

If you expect your friends to be there for you without you returning anything, you are abusing them. That isn't friendship, that is exploitation.

And if your friend is there for you even though you are incapable of returning anything, it is incredibly romantic. But also usually very limited, because that drain on your friend has consequences and needs to either be equalized by something (not you) or suck your friend dry until he himself is incapable. Which is a very un-romantic ending, because it leaves the world with 2 emotional cripples.

For me, friendship is also very much about knowing the limits of what i should make my friends suffer through.


life is swings and roundabouts. having nothing to give in return isn't romantic - it's humbling. it's depressing and devastating the one who has no choice but to accept and I'd rather they get out of their dump than thinking about my expectations. it's more important that they're OK to me than if they give back (which I trust will anyway happen because "swings & roundabouts").

I understand most people are more calculating. My own family who would keep tabs of what they give and receive so to never feeling they're in somebody#s debt. I'm like that in business situations, and to those who I know would do it to me, but not to those who are close enough to consider friend.

> for me, friendship is also very much about knowing the limits of what i should make my friends suffer through.

yes, this very much!


You're making assumptions that you won't find yourself in the same state one day where you require the selfless help of others.


No, I'm not. While I would appreciate help in such a situation, I can fully understand anyone walking away. Being a bother to people and needy is one of the worst parts of being ill.


Thinking your depressed friend is a bother to yourself has told me that I'm very blessed you and I are not friends.


If you have a treatable form of depression, go get treated. If you have a personality disorder, the person you're responding to is the lucky one, not you.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: