Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> +1 for the minimal

You used it correctly. The term minimal has been hijacked to mean something entirely different these days. It often means “I’ve thrown away important bits so the design looks sexy, I can list it on SiteInspire and get kudos from my friends for following too much white space and anti-functionalism trends”.

> HN-friendly design

We need to own this. When newcomers, youngsters and uninformed people want to be inspired, they’ll instead see this as “Old fashioned, grumpy, nerdy HN-friendly design”. There, we killed it already.

That said - This web design has some short comings. For me the legibility is compromised by using a fixed width typeface, line-spacing is too tight and paragraph column width is too large.



While I generally agree with your sentiment, I did want to point out that you lambast the minimalist movement for adding white space, then critique this site for not having enough white space.


> "I’ve thrown away important bits so the design looks sexy"

"Important bits" is just about as subjective as "looks sexy", is it not?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: