Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Depends if the system is open or closed and if mass is converting to energy or visa versa. Also conditions near big bang are not representative.


More fundamentally, energy is a conserved quantity because the laws of physics are time invariant. See Noethers theorem and gauge symmetries.


that's wrong. Noether's theorem says that "energy is conserved" is equivalent to "the laws of physics are time invariant". If you assert that "energy is conserved" because "the laws are time invariant" that risks begging the question. At the very least you should be asking "ok, then, why are the laws of physics time invariant?"

We know that all of the laws of physics we observe at the local scale are time invariant, but that is not necessarily true for any law we haven't discovered yet. While on the local scale that feels so unlikely as for it to be basically considered "inviolable without extraordinary evidence", that is not necessarily the case in the community for laws at the cosmic scale.


Nope, talking about post BB conditions.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: