Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Here's a perfect example of the United States government running as a business (and completely failing its job to protect its citizens):

You know our emergency grain reserves? The reserves that hold up to 4 million metric tons of wheat, corn, sorghum, and rice, in case food supplies are interrupted?

Yeah. They sold everything in the reserves back in 2008. Since then, the trust is solely a cash reserve, invested in low-risk, short-term securities or instruments.

How the hell is cash supposed to save us, if there isn't actually any physical grain to be had?

For more info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Emerson_Humanitarian_Trus...



When I see things like this I like to consider perhaps I know less about these things than the people in charge.

So I wonder, what where the sequence of events and decisions that lead to this outcome? and who were the people that made those decisions, and who are the people who continue to maintain that state of affairs and what is their rationale?


I also wonder exactly these same things. I'm not sure how to find out the answers though?

I would assume that the emergency reserves would have been expensive to maintain, with high amounts of spoilage.

I'm guessing that someone involved simply said, "Hey, you know, the free market has millions of tons of grain for sale right now. If there was an emergency, we could just buy what we need! Let's sell this pile of spoiling grain and just hang onto the cash! Cash will only increase in value, while grain is a depreciating asset."

But what they failed to realize (in my opinion) is that in times of famine (due to things like global warming or whatever), the free market's grain prices will skyrocket, and the grain reserves on the free market will most likely dwindle before we even realize there is an emergency.

I would like to see them stockpiling a constantly rotating reserve of grain, with old grain being constantly sold off, and new grain constantly being bought (to limit spoilage waste). If they did that, they could isolate our grain reserves and ensure the army had food to distribute even when times were tough and grain prices were extremely high.


I'm in Australia. My initial internet searches for Australian strategic food reserves / stockpiles don't seem to turn up anything.

Thinking about climate change here in Australia, and how some areas have been subject to quite persistent drought, it doesn't seem completely inconceivable that the whole continent could have a bad season.

Having said that, we do export a lot of grain, so you'd think if we'd be able to reduce / halt exports and still feed the nation maybe?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: