Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

While a certain amount of cynicism is healthy and it should be acknowledged that Google can always back track, I'm still happy that for now they've decided not to assist and facilitate one of the most Orwellian nation's to ever exist.


They are just waiting for the right moment to try again.


> I'm still happy that for now they've decided not to assist and facilitate one of the most Orwellian nation's to ever exist.

Don’t get too excited; they haven’t announced a lack of participation in PRISM yet.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/06/us-tech-giants...


What would you want Google to say?

"I’m not sure I can say this more clearly: we’re not in cahoots with the NSA and there’s is no government program that Google participates in that allows the kind of access that the media originally reported. Note that I say “originally” because you’ll see that many of those original sources corrected their articles after it became clear that the PRISM slides were not accurate. Now, what does happen is that we get specific requests from the government for user data. We review each of those requests and push back when the request is overly broad or doesn’t follow the correct process. There is no free-for-all, no direct access, no indirect access, no back door, no drop box."

https://venturebeat.com/2013/06/19/google-issues-clearest-st...

(I work at Google, not in a relevant role.)


"We are moving our entire business to Europe, because we legally cannot keep the NSA out of your data otherwise." would be a start.


That would just move the ball into GCHQ or DGSE's court.


I said it would be a start, not a final solution.


The start of what? There's no reason to assume non-Europeans would prefer British, French, or EU jurisdiction over the current situation.


Either Ed Snowden is lying, or Google is.


Or he wasn't lying, but didn't himself have fully accurate information. Just like a big organization, there may have been a lot of work (and slides generated) on a project that was ultimately killed/changed significantly.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: