Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Using a reward card and taking FB quizzes are active decisions. Being surreptitiously recorded is not.


Well, they made an active decision to buy a device specifically meant to record them and provide responses to said recording. It would be another thing to find out a phone records every conversation passively, but these devices are literally made for the purposes of recording you.

That kind of sounds like a self inflicted wound if they actually cared about privacy.

This is all said with the presumption that the devices actually are surreptitiously recording. Which is far from proven but already addressed by other comments here.


OK, by your definition of "recording", a laptop contains several I/O devices that "record" my input, not just webcam and microphone, but keyboard as well. I guess I should just shrug at the revelation that it comes with a keylogger. Because hey, if I didn't want my written thoughts to be recorded, why did I buy a memory-enabled Internet-connected device to do actually that?


Don't put words into my mouth, I never said that.

I even used the example of a phone recording you being bad because that wasn't the primary purpose of the device when bought. That argument obviously applies to laptops for the same reason.

But if you as a consumer decide to buy a device who's literal only purpose is to record you, then you don't also get to cry out about it recording you. That's the very definition of a self inflicted wound.


The primary purpose of an Efho device is not to record you. You brought up a silly argument.


It has 7 microphones and its only purpose is to record you, then respond to your request. That's literally the only thing the device is made to do.


And a laptop has a keyboard and memory to explicitly record what you write. That doesn't make installing a keylogger the same thing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: