Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What fact?

The fact that apple have the most popular ecosystem out there with nothing even close.

The fact that everyone knows how to install an app on the iphone.

The fact that the iPhone helped introduce the idea of an application to the general consumer.

The fact that the iPhone just works and is consistently thought through, the UI is easy to use.

The fact that apple not anyone else solved the GUI for touch screens.

iPod, iPhone, iPad what can I say they all resolve around the most lucrative ecoystem that exist besides the internet itself.

The fact that when you want to write for iPhone you write one an distribute to all devices.

Want to write for Android? Good luck. Ask Tweetdeck how many versions they had to develop to get out on as many android versions as possible.

I am not even talking about the number of apps that each store have.

I am talking about the in my mind pretty simple fact that an android with only one market and one system to develop to is better for both the the consumer and developer than 3 different markets and who knows how many permutations of the android platform that exist out there today.



I'm not going to address this point-by-point, because very little of it has to do with ease-of-use for either the consumer or the developer.

I'll give you this - writing for iPhone is certainly easier in the sense that you only have to write for one (maybe two) software versions. However, take a look at Tweetdeck's later response to the comments : that they had a team of TWO to deal with versioning. Sure, it's a bit of a hassle, but there are always trade-offs.

That's also not the only consideration. There are many factors - App pricing, prior programming experience, target market, etc. that play into making an application. Not only that, having one market and one system is not necessarily better, and it's definitely not a fact.

It comes back to the issue of competition; I'm not talking about Android vs. iPhone; I mean the competition between developers in putting out applications that are meaningful and easy to use. Neither system (right now) is inherently better, and I think that casting it in the light of integration vs. fragmentation turns the spotlight in the wrong direction.


Want to write for Android? Good luck. Ask Tweetdeck how many versions they had to develop to get out on as many android versions as possible.

Yes, why don't you ask them: http://twitter.com/iaindodsworth/status/27813709366




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: