Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>In the UAE, where VoIP is illegal, the government was not able to selectively block voice traffic since it is indistinguishable from text traffic. So they had to ask WhatsApp to block voice functionality whenever a user is in the UAE.

Authorities can selectively block WhatsApp voice calls, it's been done in Oman where I used to live. If I leave Oman and use WhatsApp in an uncensored country, voice calls work just fine.

This is not the case where WhatsApp is registered via a UAE number; the blocks persist no matter where you connect from.



> Authorities can selectively block WhatsApp voice calls, it's been done in Oman where I used to live.

But they cannot do it without WhatsApp's help. My understanding is that WhatsApp will check the following at the server side:

1) User IP in UAE/Oman/etc.? Block voice.

2) User's number registered in UAE/Oman/etc.? Block voice.

This is different from UAE/Oman blocking voice traffic without coordination with WhatsApp.


They don't need WhatsApp's help to do it. WhatsApp voice calls are done over different ports, so only these need to be blocked.

The UAE (and Saudi Arabia) went through the extra step of asking WhatsApp to perform a block server side because of legal regulatory issues. Oman has made no such demand.

My family regularly makes WhatsApp calls to me from Oman; they just have to switch on a VPN to tunnel out of Oman's censorware.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: