Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The Final Days of DRM: Yahoo Music Store Closing, Will Eat Your Purchased Music (readwriteweb.com)
20 points by wave on July 24, 2008 | hide | past | favorite | 16 comments


I wouldn't say just yet that DRM is in it's final days. People have downloaded over 5 billion tunes from iTunes, and it's the US's biggest music retailer with something like 80%+ market share.

Yes, Apple does offer DRM-free tracks, but those have only been available there for about a year. And does anyone know if they're yet doing this with any labels other than EMI?

DRM use does seem to be declining, but it's going to be a while yet before it disappears completely.


The funny thing is that stories like Yahoo's and Microsoft's are the reason DRM is declining.

If the record companies really cared about DRM, they would provide a service to distribute keys once an online music store closes... instead of creating a mass of disenfranchised customers who will think twice before buying DRM-laden music again.

But, no, they'd rather monetize the customer's convenience than protect their music.


They'll get more DRM-free tracks when and if the RIAA gives up on trying to crush them:

http://weblog.raganwald.com/2008/05/why-apple-is-more-expens...


The reason Yahoo Music store is closing is b/c the DRM was very poor -- partly due to Microsoft's technology and partly due to Yahoo's flaky and untested music player software.

Apple is keeping DRM going strong with movies. Let us hope that rather than dying, DRM innovation continues.


This could just as easily been titled "Another Music Store Falls to the iTunes Juggernaut"


Yeah, but what matters is that people are losing music over this one.


I agree that's a big deal, I was just critiquing the "End of DRM" headline as being misleading and pushing an (untrue) agenda.


Point taken. But then, we nerds are prone to sensationalism over facts just as everybody else is. Proof: TechCrunch, the current reddit userbase.


What are the popular and good mp3 stores out there that don't use DRM?


Amazon's doesn't, I don't think. iTunes Plus is DRM-free as well.


bleep.com was one of the first, and is still quite good. They stock the entire Warp catalog, as well as lots of other smaller ones (catering to indie rock, dub, electronic, etc.) such as Domino, etc.


I always liked emusic.


Since I actually worked on something closely tied to the Yahoo Music property (NOT on the DRM side, don't worry!) when I was with Yahoo, I'm sad to see it closing. I know several folks who may be out of a job because of this news. Sad.

I think when Ian Rogers left, that was the beginning of the end: http://mashable.com/2008/04/03/ian-rogers-leaves-yahoo/


All I can say is this: Told you so.

DRM was a broken concept from the start.

Let's move on.


Amen. Although let's all acknowledge the music industry will try it again in another form. They just never learn.


It's all your fault for not sticking to records.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: